A Mayfair-inspired social club that trades neighborhood-curry-house energy for British-Indian polish. Intensely Punjabi, despite the address.
By Tony Abraham
VisitedOctober 25, 2025
CuisinePunjabi
NeighborhoodNoMad
Ambassadors Clubhouse offers a vibe that's more Mayfair social club than your traditional neighborhood curry house — modern, sophisticated, and leaning heavily into a British-Indian aesthetic. While the interior is polished, the food is the undisputed protagonist here. The decor looks toward London; the kitchen keeps its heart firmly in Northern India.
———
Small Plates
Pappad & Paan Patta Chaat
The pappad assortment is a solid selection of textures, though the real stars are the chutneys — the mint chutney in particular is vibrant and punchy, the kind that elevates everything it touches.
The Paan Patta & Kaala Channa Chaat is one of the best chaats in recent memory. It's a flavorful explosion — spicy, tangy, and drenched in a killer sauce that ties the betel leaf and chickpeas together perfectly. A masterclass in a dish that often gets phoned in.
———
Small Plates
Chilli Cheese Pakode & Wild Jheenga
The Chilli Cheese Pakode are deceptively simple. The cheese balls themselves are standard — but they serve as a vessel for a tomato-garlic achar sauce that I'd honestly put on a shoe and eat. It strikes that elusive balance of sweet, tangy, and savory.
The Ajwaini Wild Jheenga arrives beautifully presented and well-seasoned. The prawns are high-quality, though, given their size, an extra sixty seconds in the tandoor might have perfected the texture. The mint chutney returns to elevate this to glad-I-ordered-it status.
———
Main
OG BBQ Butter Chicken Chops
New York has a Butter Chicken problem, but Ambassadors might have the cure. It's flavorful without being cloying or overly creamy, making it feel lighter than the usual grease-bomb versions you find around the city.
The chicken wasn't the most tender I've had, but the flavor profile is spot on — exactly what this dish should be when handled with restraint. A welcome reset for a dish that has lost its way in most kitchens.
———
Main
Matka Baliram Lamb
The lamb is technically well-executed — tender and falling apart. While the flavor is deep, it does lean slightly salty, and by this point in the meal, the richness feels quite heavy.
It's a good dish, just perhaps one that requires a very empty stomach to fully appreciate. Order it earlier in the meal, or share it across the table.
———
Dessert
Gur Malai Toast
Unfortunately, the meal ended on a flat note. While the presentation is stunning, the flavors don't quite land. The burnt ghee ice cream lacked the depth I expected, and the jaggery caramel failed to pull the elements together.
The toast was crispy, but overall, the dish felt less like a grand finale and more like a missed opportunity. The kitchen has clearly thought about this plate; it just hasn't quite landed it yet.
From the Bar
Liquid Notes
Order
Masala Margarita
A masterclass in balance. A spicy rendition that respects the palate — not too alcohol-forward and not aggressively hot. The subtle smokiness of mezcal plays beautifully with the classic margarita profile, finishing with a surprising, refreshing cilantro aftertaste.
The Verdict
Dish Deconstructed
A four-pillar framework. One to five.
First Bite
3
/ 5
Flavor Journey
4
/ 5
Technical Execution
3
/ 5
Order Again
4
/ 5
Honestly Speaking
Order the Paan Patta Chaat and the Chilli Cheese Pakode — that tomato-garlic achar is the meal's MVP. The OG Butter Chicken Chops may be the city's cure for the butter chicken problem.